Compare · Acquisition Infrastructure · Brief 39
Landing Page OS for Solo Consultants:
Carrd vs Squarespace vs Leadpages.
Carrd at $19/year does 80% of what Leadpages does at 0.5% of the annual cost — for most solo consultants. The difference is paid traffic. If you're not running ads, you almost certainly don't need Leadpages. Here's the framework for choosing correctly. Updated May 2026.
Updated: May 2026 · Pricing verifiedThe extraction tool
Do you actually need a dedicated landing page tool?
Most consultants treat landing pages as a website problem and try to solve it with a website rebuild. A landing page is an extraction tool — you pull one offer out of your full site, remove all navigation and exit ramps, and point traffic at a single CTA. Most full-site builders aren't designed for this. Their templates assume you want menus, footers, about pages, and sidebar links — exactly what kills conversion on a focused page.
Answer these two questions first: (1) Do you need a dedicated landing page tool at all, or will a page on your main site work? (2) If a dedicated tool, which one matches your actual use case, traffic volume, and budget? The price range runs from $9/year to $99/month — and Carrd at $19/year does 80% of what Leadpages does at 0.5% of the annual cost.
When a page on your main site is fine
You already have Squarespace and can disable the nav on a specific page. You're on Webflow and can build a stripped-down template. You need only one or two focused pages and have no paid traffic to optimise. In these cases, a dedicated landing page tool adds cost without adding meaningful value.
When a dedicated tool is worth it
You need to strip navigation entirely and your main site builder makes this painful. You're running paid traffic and need native conversion analytics. You want to test multiple headline variants without touching your main site. You need multiple campaign-specific pages to stay separate from the main site architecture.
Tool snapshots
The honest comparison.
Carrd — The $19/Year Option Most Consultants Overlook
Minimalist single-page site builder optimised for simplicity and speed-to-live. Fastest path from blank page to live URL — typical Carrd build takes 30–90 minutes. Zero maintenance overhead. Clean, mobile-responsive templates that don't look DIY. Works well as a "burner" landing page for a single campaign without touching the main site. Adequate email capture via widget integrations (Kit, Mailchimp, Zapier).
| Plan | Price |
|---|---|
| Pro Lite | $9/year |
| Pro Standard | $19/year — custom domains, forms, email capture, no branding |
| Pro Plus | $49/year — up to 25 sites, custom forms, developer features |
Limitations to know: No native A/B testing or conversion analytics. No multi-step forms. Not suitable as a full website replacement. Widgets embed via iFrame — functional but not native. Best for: Consultants who need a fast, cheap, credible single page for a lead magnet, waitlist, or one-offer service page.
Squarespace — Already Have It? Use It.
Best-in-class design quality. Full website + landing page in one subscription — avoids paying for two tools. The right choice if you're already on Squarespace and want to add campaign-specific pages. Building a "true" landing page (no nav, stripped footer, single CTA) requires workaround CSS or Business plan's custom code access. No built-in A/B testing at any plan tier. Monthly cost is 15–25x Carrd's annual cost for the same single-page use case.
Best for: Consultants already using Squarespace as their main site who want to add campaign-specific pages without a second tool.
Leadpages — When Conversion Analytics Actually Matter
Purpose-built conversion platform. The only tool in this comparison with meaningful built-in conversion analytics and A/B testing at entry-level price points. Built-in A/B testing (Optimize plan), real-time conversion guidance (the "conversion meter" scores pages before launch), AI page creation, native lead capture with direct integrations for most email tools. Unlimited traffic on all plans.
| Plan | Price |
|---|---|
| Grow | $49/mo — 5 pages, 1 domain, basic builder |
| Optimize | $99/mo — unlimited pages, A/B testing, full analytics, AI creation |
The honest case against: At $49/month minimum, Leadpages is 30× Carrd's annual cost. Conversion tooling earns its cost when traffic volume generates statistically meaningful test results — typically 1,000+ unique visitors per variant per month. For organic-only solo consultants, the analytics aren't statistically useful. Best for: Consultants actively running paid traffic who need to measure cost-per-lead at the page level, or those with multiple offers requiring separate optimised pages.
The Alternatives Worth Knowing
Notion + Super.so: Super.so publishes any Notion page as a clean, branded public URL — Personal plan $16/month. The right fit for Notion-native consultants who want a public-facing page without a new tool. Limitations are real: no native forms, no A/B testing, no conversion analytics. Email capture requires embedding a third-party form. Best for: a public resource page, "work with me" overview, or waitlist page.
Kit (ConvertKit) Landing Pages: Free on all Kit plans including the free tier. Integrated directly with Kit's email sequences — lead capture is native, no Zapier needed. Limited template variety and design control. Best for: consultants already on Kit who need a simple opt-in page for a lead magnet. Zero incremental cost if Kit is already the email tool of record.
Unbounce: Build plan $74/month (annual), Experiment $112/month. The gold standard for paid-traffic teams running multi-variant tests at scale. Smart Traffic (AI routing to best-converting variant) is genuinely differentiated. Skip it unless you're already managing $5K+/month in ad spend.
Decision framework
Five questions to find your tool.
Q1 — Do you already have a tool that could serve this function?
Already on Squarespace → use it. Already on Kit → use their free landing pages. Only buy a new tool if your current stack has a genuine gap — not just a familiarity gap.
Q2 — Are you running paid traffic to this page?
Spending more than $1,000/month on ads → Leadpages or Unbounce likely pays for itself through measurable CRO lift. Organic-only traffic → A/B testing and analytics are nice-to-have but rarely essential at solo consultant traffic volumes.
Q3 — How quickly do you need to deploy?
This week → Carrd or Kit landing pages. Both can be live with a custom domain within two hours. Squarespace and Leadpages both have steeper first-time setup curves.
Q4 — How many pages in the next 12 months?
One or two → Carrd Pro Standard ($19/year). Three to ten, different designs and CTAs → Leadpages Optimize or Squarespace Business becomes more defensible. More than ten across campaigns and domains → Leadpages or Unbounce.
Q5 — Lead magnet delivery, discovery call booking, or waitlist?
All three of these use cases → any tool works; Kit landing pages are free if you're already on Kit. None of these require Leadpages unless paid traffic is in the picture.
Archetype configurations
The right tool by situation.
New Solo Consultant (Pre-Revenue, Budget-Constrained)
Carrd Pro Standard ($19/year) + Kit free plan — total: $19/year
Carrd for the public-facing page, Kit's native landing pages for lead magnet opt-ins specifically. At sub-500 visitors/month, Leadpages' monthly cost exceeds the value. Invest in content and outreach instead.
Established Consultant Adding Conversion Infrastructure
Leadpages Optimize ($99/mo annual)
Growing email list, running one or two lead magnets, wants to test multiple headlines and offer angles. Leadpages' A/B testing and conversion analytics pay for themselves if even one test produces a 20% lift on a page driving meaningful traffic. Wire to Kit or ActiveCampaign via native integration.
Notion-Native Consultant
Notion + Super.so Personal ($16/mo) + Tally or Kit form embedded
Deep Notion user — entire workflow lives there. Super.so keeps the stack consolidated. Accept the limitations: no A/B testing, no native analytics, limited design control. Upgrade trigger: when you want a structured lead magnet funnel with email sequences, move to Kit landing pages or Carrd + Kit.
Paid-Traffic Consultant
Leadpages Optimize or Unbounce Build ($74/mo annual)
Running Google Ads, LinkedIn Ads, or Meta. Cost-per-lead is a tracked metric. At this level, conversion rate differences of 2–3% are meaningful in dollar terms. Carrd is a black box for paid traffic — you can't optimise what you can't measure.
Bottom line
Start with Carrd unless paid traffic is already in your plan. The $19/year Pro Standard investment has the highest ROI-per-dollar of any tool in this comparison for organic-only solo consultants. Upgrade to Leadpages when you're spending money on traffic and need to prove which page variant converts better.
Get the Solo Consultant OS Blueprint
Five-layer OS architecture, tool selection by practice stage, and automation wiring — free for subscribers.
- Five-layer OS framework
- Tool selection by practice stage
- Make automation scenarios
- Weekly OS Review template
Free for subscribers
No spam. Unsubscribe any time.
Related reading